An Ear For An Era: 1972

It started out bold, got boring for awhile, then got better. Or something like that. 1972 was not a great year for soul in my opinion despite a few landmark albums released. The highlights were in the glam/power pop/whatever genre it's considered. I think they go together. And singer/songwriters had a great year as well. Stuff was music back then, you know? You don't?

Stevie Wonder's Talking Book is kind of maybe the first in his famous great-70s-albums series, but most of it seemed to be ballads and kind of bored me (although I did appreciate the many layers of orchestration). Still, "Superstition" was on the album so that was an obvious highlight. I think I like his later stuff a bit more though, it gets deeper and more complex soon.

Then a string of R&B popped up and it was all kind of continually weightless. Bill Withers, Allen Toussaint, Roberta Flack with Donny Hathaway, Jr. Walker, Smokey Robinson...all artists I do quite like, but this all seemed too slight, flighty. Too many ballads, not enough funk.

Then Can came back on. And oddly was the funkiest thing I'd heard yet. Yes, the album Ege Bamyasi is quite a bit more grounded and accessible than Tago Mago, mostly because of shorter song lengths, lots of funky rhythms, and the song "Vitamin C," which was kind of a hit I believe. But my mind was completely blown when "Vitamin C" ended and "Soup" came on. The longest song on the album, it was advanced post punk before punk was even a thing. Crazy rhythms, blasts of guitar, screaming vocals, shifting time signatures and tempos, a drawn out version of loud (and fast) - quiet (and slow) - loud (and fast and slow) dynamics.

Can "Soup"

I don't have a good transition out of Can because there's really nothing else like them in this era in my library. How about back to soul, but the more positive stuff I have to say?

Maybe I just don't have any of the possibly great possibly popular funk of the day. But the best I got was from compilations of obscure stuff, like The Funky 16 Corners (Ernie And The Top Notes Inc. had a great song called "Dap Walk.") and Eccentric Soul: The Prix Label (Chip Willis & Double Exposure!).

The main, kind-of-funky, cinematic and great soul album (ok obviously it's cinematic, but I'm just saying he did a great job with it) was Curtis Mayfield's Superfly, the soundtrack to the movie. It's tough not to compare it to Isaac Hayes' Shaft, but it really is a different beast. Lots of very apt commentary in the lyrics (and lots more songs with lyrics!), Mayfield's completely different style of arrangements, it does really feel more like an album to listen through in a sitting without needing any context of the movie to go along with it.

And that's it for soul. Awkward transition to singer songwriter types?

Lou Reed solo. The album is called Transformer. It has his gigantic hit "Walk On The Wild Side." It has more of those sentimental songs in the style that I liked so much in the later Velvet Underground material, such as "Perfect Day." That may be my favorite. Or maybe "Hangin' Round" is my favorite. The line from the chorus, "You're still doing things that I gave up years ago" seems pretty apt considering the history of the Velvet Underground and how influential they were. Not that that seems to be what this is about.

Now the last we'll hear from Rodriguez (unless he decides to put something new out one of these days), some bonus stuff recorded after his last album that can be found as bonus tracks on the reissue as well as the Searching For Sugarman soundtrack. I just wanted an excuse to post this song, as he was slipping away from the music biz.

Rodriguez "I'll Slip Away"

We're also hearing our last of Nick Drake (other than a posthumous album that will be waaaay later). Such a tragic loss. Such a beautiful album Pink Moon was, appropriately sparse in a time when more and more music was getting overproduced. All short simple folk songs, mostly just a guitar and vocals.

Harry Nilsson followed up on the great Nilsson Schmilsson with Son of Schmilsson. I have a long standing opinion of this album as kind of a big laugh, not too memorable or really much of a successor to his probably-greatest achievement, but this time I realized that amongst all the joke lyrics ("I sang my balls off for you baby..." "Let me be your Joy boy," "You're breakin' my heart, tearin' it apart so f*** you," "I'd rather be dead than wet my bed...") there is a lot of Nilsson's impeccable vocals and plenty of heartbreak and authenticity. "You're Breakin' My Heart" is kind of the spiritual grandfather of Shellac's "Prayer To God," which is an id-driven, raw expression of heartbreak that can make you laugh through your own pain (at least both of those songs worked for me when I went through heartbreak). Still a silly follow up to Schmilsson, but far from something to be dismissed.

Neil Young's Harvest is yet another brilliant album, a very worthy successor to After The Gold Rush. I don't feel the need to say much aside from the fact that it's the album with "Old Man," "The Needle & The Damage Done," and "Alabama." What else do you need, man?

A couple words about Kris Kristofferson. He started sounding just slightly more 70s country on Jesus Was A Capricorn, but at this point it was pretty subtle and he still had some brilliant songs. It's not quite on the level of his first two albums but still quite enjoyable.

Rock & Roll! The Rolling Stones' Exile on Main Street may be my favorite Stones album. Mostly because the double album is usually something bands will use to indulge in more experimental material because hey, everything fits, but the Stones just kind of made their rockin' more loose and fun and wild. Then the slower songs are all winners. Particularly "Sweet Virginia." Yep.

Rolling Stones "Sweet Virginia"

Big Star popped up. I was definitely in the 70s based on the fact that the song "In The Street" came on. The one that was covered as the theme for That 70s Show! So there's that. But seriously, #1 Record is damned amazing. Of course the song "Thirteen" is one of the best throwback nostalgia tunes that will remind anyone of grade school crushes. Something very authentic in the songwriting considering this was basically pop music.

Big Star "Thirteen"

I like to think Big Star alongside the glam heroes of this time. T-Rex came on shortly afterwards with their album The Slider and I found a lot of parallels in the atmosphere developed. More authentic, lovely songs but with a bit more edge...

And it ended of course with the ultimate 1972 album, the ultimate in the world of glam rock, and possibly the ultimate David Bowie album:  The Rise And Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders From Mars. Front to back, just a great album of space travel, song structure experimentation, protopunk, and glam party music.

Where I Stand: 4537 of 37161

Other Highlights Worth Mentioning:

• It actually started with Alice Cooper. "School's Out." Yeah!
• A couple Johnny Cash cuts...I'm not sure when he totally fell off the radar, but "Jacob Green" was from this year so maybe he was still doing all right.
• Chuck Berry had some sort of comeback as he had the live hit "My Ding-A-Ling." I have the full 9 minute version and some sort of edited short version. Maybe not a song that needs to be 9 minutes.
• Michael Jackson's version of "Rockin' Robin." That goes out to my sister.
• We say goodbye to Ricky Nelson here with "Garden Party." A nice sentimental song about an earlier era of rock & roll.
• Aretha Franklin's Young, Gifted and Black kind of toed all the different lines of the different directions soul was heading, from the overproduced lightweight stuff, a bit of funk, and a bit of disco. 
• Elvis! "Burning Love."
• Some more post-Morrison Doors, the song "The Mosquito" is quite the curiosity.

On The Next Installment...

Soul is Al Green, Curtis Mayfield, Barry White, Marvin Gaye, Stevie Wonder is definitely in his stride, and others. More Bowie (I think pretty much every year will have some sort of Bowie for the 70s). Iggy & The Stooges have a finale. The return of James Brown. Band on the Run. Quadrophenia. And these guys all make their AEFAE debut: New York Dolls! Pink Floyd! Queen! Roxy Music! Tom Waits! Willie Nelson!

An Ear For An Era: 1970

And so begins another decade. A bummer decade? The decade where everything got overly polished and the hippies stopped and everything got lame? Until eventually punk rock came along to put an end to that stuff?

That may be generally true, but this is based on my music. I don't have much crap in my collection. So the 70s here is going to be where it starts shifting more away from the mainstream. Because there was still lots of great stuff happening. For 1970, it mostly means funk and folk.

But it's kind of a gradual change. I still have all the old people that were making music in the 60s, continuing into the 70s, and it's not like they suddenly sucked. Let's talk about some of that and some other things.

It started with the end of The Beatles. Which I appreciated, because I was hoping it'd come on before the solo projects started up. Just as I skewed the results so I'd listen to Led Zeppelin I before Led Zeppelin II, I was hoping Let It Be would come on before the post-Beatles solo work. Let It Be. Well, it does kind of sound more like the solo careers than The Beatles. Beatles Beatles Beatles. Get it out of your system because this is going to be the end of writing about The Beatles for awhile. Uhhhh...it has classics like "Let It Be" and "Across The Universe." And over-produced messiness. And I kinda like "For You Blue." And I think "Get Back" should have been played harder, like "Helter Skelter." This album version is just kind of a boring way to end things. Abbey Road should have been the proper end.

How about those solo projects though, huh? Those're something! I didn't have Macca's solo album digitally so I can't speak to that, but George's was very much the work of someone that only got to have one or two songs on the albums his band put out. A triple album? My Sweet Lord! But it's quite great. And Lennon's was pretty interesting as well. Just from those two you can see the different directions they may have wanted to take The Beatles. Hey! I mentioned them again! It's also interesting that Harrison's was called All Things Must Pass, and Lennon's had that song about how "the dream is over." Actually I'll say something about that song. It's called "God" and sings about all the things Lennon doesn't believe in, kind of a way to tear down idols and whatnot, but when it gets to "I don't believe in Beatles," the whole rest of the song is about how they're not a band anymore. I know they were kind of to a point of being idolized at that point but it just seems kind of not focused to me.

You know who wasn't breaking up? The Who. In fact, they were playing Live At Leeds! So that's one of the first vinyl albums I ever bought (yes, this was in a time after CDs existed, so it's not one of the first ALBUMS I ever bought, I'm not that cool), and I was mostly excited about the 15 minute rendition of "My Generation." Of course, it turned out to be more of a medley than anything, but it ruled. It's a quality live album.

It's been a little while since I heard from the Beach Boys but Sunflower is quite a good way to bring them back in. Dig the Dennis Wilson contributions! I love/hate the song "Forever." It's such a great ballad, but it had to be sung by Jesse and the Rippers on Full House which makes me also kind of hate it. But I still kind of love it!

And The Kinks. Lola Versus Powerman and the Money Go Round is quite the title for an album. The song "Lola," is that supposed to be a guilty pleasure? Because most music snobs seem to hate the song (although they otherwise appreciate this album) but I still dig the song. It's kind of silly, but it was pretty forward in how it blurred gender lines without passing judgment. Plus I like it because of "Yoda" by Weird Al Yankovic. Most of the rest of the album is as cynical as Arthur, only this time it's more about the music industry instead of war. And I dig me some cynical Kinks. But the most gorgeous song on the album, I think everyone can agree on it, and it's not cynical at all. It's just pretty:

The Kinks, "Strangers"

You know, it's kind of surprising to me that I quite enjoyed Derek & The Dominoes' Layla and Other Assorted Love Songs. Since I didn't like Cream and thought they sounded to 70s in the 60s, I figured this'd be even more 70s-ish. But instead it's really just simple blues songs that give plenty of room for Clapton to wail on the guitar, and that just makes for a very enjoyable listening experience.

The Stooges are something completely different! And Fun House was already something completely different from their first album. Well not completely different. But it seems a bit slower. Just a hair. It still rocks harder than anything else I heard from this year. Turn it up! Also the song "Dirt" is so great, so menacing as it just grooves right along.

I keep not talking about stuff from those Eccentric Soul compilations other than small name-drops here and there. But off the Capsoul Label collection, I have to talk about Marion Black a bit. Not that I can say too much based on two songs, but he has such a wonderful voice and I wish there was more out there. How was he not super popular? It's not like his sound is all that "eccentric." Just a sad breakup ballad ("Go On Fool") and a groovy dose of cool:

Marion Black, "Who Knows"

Other soul was good. Did you know The Jackson 5 released "ABC" this year? Kind of a sign of the disco-doomed direction Motown was headed but I still love these early Jackson 5 cuts. And "You Keep Me Hangin' On" by The Supremes. And we got the start of Diana's solo career! And Stevie Wonder in the 70s is something to keep an ear out for, and for 1970 that means the single "Signed Sealed Delivered."

But the obvious most favorable direction soul was taking was to a funkier place. 1969 had a lot of funk and it seems people just wanted to out-funk each other. Funk each other's brains out. James Brown had "Sex Machine." Slim and the Soulful Saints had a song called "Fish Head." Blood Sweat and Tears went super funky with "Lucretia MacEvil" (I blame this song for making me think everything else they'd do would be so funky). Tower of Power's East Bay Grease has kind of the perfect album title for the music contained therein. Greasy funk. We played some Tower of Power in marching band in high school because we had an awesome teacher so I really admire how damn tight that horn section is. It's just so dirty and foonky and great. And Jimmy McGriff with stuff like "Fat Cakes" and "Blue Juice," and The Meters' "Chicken Strut" (complete with chicken sounds) kept everything light but funky. funk funk funk funk funk funk funk. 

Merry Clayton always has to be written about. Crap, now wikipedia says her album Gimme Shelter came out in 1969! Whoops! Anyway, it's such an enjoyable album even if it follows the trend of the time of being full of covers. But I kind of see it like a Bettye LaVette album. Taking great songs and spinning them into a great funky version that is also a great song? Does that make any sense? Here's a song that doesn't reflect that, because it's not a cover and it is a ballad:

Merry Clayton, "I Ain't Gonna Worry My Life Away"

And...ska! Toots & The Maytals' "Monkey Man" is what made me get that whole anthology set in the first place. And they also had "Pressure Drop," another one that would be covered years later by another influential band. Another fun song (that just missed the "moon/space song trend of 1969" by a year) is "Skinhead Moonstomp" by Symarip. 

Let's change the subject again. Bitches Brew by Miles Davis is one of those things. Fusion, they call this thing. And I apologize for not speaking for accurately about this, but I'm still very much a novice about jazz. And I know I missed a lot (or all) of his 60s output that got him here. Still I very much enjoy most of this album. Some of the guitar based stuff I don't like as much as other guitar jazz (such as the Sonny Sharrock from 1969). It's not as good when you think of it as bringing rock to jazz as it is when you think of it as bringing jazz to rock. I don't care it makes no sense! Care not, ye, for what is important is that "Pharaoh's Dance" sounds so sinister and Egyptian, and "Sanctuary" takes you to a place of peace. It takes me there at least. 

What else is arty? To a degree, The Velvet Underground are. They used to be so art and then they got so pop, like a bunch of Campbell's soup cans or pictures of Marilyn Monroe. Every one of these makes me long for the wild experimentation of the previous. I think they're running out of my collection here with Loaded. I don't think they're coming back up. So just like The Beatles, it's time to say goodbye to a band here with one of their weaker(ish) efforts. Not that it's particularly weak. After all, this is the album with "Sweet Jane" on it. It's just so poppy, I don't know what they were going for. 

Their former collaborator, however, put out this great song:

Nico, "Afraid"

How about we talk about some singer songwriters?

Nilsson Sings Newman. Yes, Nilsson was a singer and Newman was a songwriter and they were also both both. I don't know why I didn't hear this one more growing up because my dad is a fan. My parents seem to know this album well (and picked "Love Story" it as a song to be played at my brother's wedding) but I mostly just grew up with Nilsson Schmilsson so I'll have a whole lot to say about that one when it comes up. But I do quite like Randy Newman's songs, and Nilsson picked some good ones to sing. 

My dad also introduced me to Kris Kristofferson, but it wasn't this self-titled debut. But I still know this self-titled debut well because I got it back before I got way too much music to be able to seriously listen to it all. So I listened to it a lot in college. It's a nice collage of political satire (not too far off from Phil Ochs if you remember what I wrote about him) and heartfelt ballads. The funny political ones sound a bit aged but the rest of the album (which is most of the album) sounds just timeless. I will say something about the satirical song "Blame It On The Stones" though. In the early 00s the song would be just as relevant if it was changed to "Blame It On Marilyn Manson" or "Blame It On Eminem." I don't know who the current scapegoat is but it's always gonna happen. But the timeless songs? Those are the ones. Kris Kristofferson is easily one of the best songwriters of the century. 

Kris Kristofferson "Just The Other Side of Nowhere"

And the Neil Young stuff! Both with CSN (Deja Vu is a great album full of hits like "Teach Your Children" and "Our House" as well as some great Neil Young solo-ish jams like "Helpless) and solo. The solo one is one of my favorite Neil Young albums: After The Gold Rush. I love my Neil Young mellow and unplugged, and this is one of the highest quality singer-songwriter albums I've ever heard. It just makes me try to sing along even though I can't sustain those notes. Mostly it just sounds so sad.

And there was Rodriguez' first album Cold Fact. Yes, I had no idea who he was before I saw that documentary Searching For Sugarman. But thank goodness for that documentary. He fits right in along with these other great early 70s singer songwriters. It really is a mystery why he couldn't find his audience. He exudes a cool not far from Lou Reed, writes lyrics not far from Bob Dylan, but doesn't really sound like anyone but himself. 

The last album I heard for 1970 (full disclosure: it actually ended with a Christmas song by Donny Hathaway) was the second album (I don't have his first, for shame!) by Nick Drake, Bryter Layter. Unfortunately I don't know what to say here about how this will shed a light on what's coming up or whatever. But I love his voice, and I wish he'd kept the arrangements a bit more spare (but that's what's coming up on Pink Moon!). I guess that's the 70s for you?

Where I Stand: 3926 of 36824 (10.66%!)

Other Highlights Worth Mentioning:

• Curtis Mayfield's debut solo album, in particular the song "(Don't Worry) If There's a Hell Below We're All Going To Go."
• The four songs I have off Simon & Garfunkel's Bridge Over Troubled Water, of course, are great.
• "Fire And Rain" by James Taylor. Cannot get enough of this song!
• Isaac Hayes had another epic version of a simple song, this time "You've Lost That Lovin' Feeling"
• Elvis' comeback must have continued as "Walk A Mile In My Shoes"
• Another bunch of Creedence songs that rule. 
• Johnny Cash's cover of "Sunday Morning Coming Down" is pretty great...Not sure why he changed the line about a kid "cussin' at a can he was kickin'" to "playin' with a can he was kickin'" but it's fine.
• Cat Stevens has entered the picture but I don't have much of anything by him.
• I thought I had a late period album by Little Richard but it turned out to be really old recordings that were finally released in 1970 so while I was going to say "wow, he put out something that sounded like T-Bone Walker in 1970? He must've been going for the nostalgia crowd!" it turns out it was just the record label that did so.
• I just got some Donny Hathaway material (just in time) mostly because he seems to be to Roberta Flack what James Taylor is to Carole King. Not much to say about him yet, but stay tuned?

On The Next Installment...

We'll see what changes from 1970 to 1971. It doesn't seem like much will. More funk, more singer/songwriters. Now let's look at the list and see if I was right: more Nilsson (THREE albums including the Nilsson Is For The Children album!), Joni Mitchell, more Rodriguez, Anthony Braxton (oooh even crazier jazz!), T Rex, Al Green (2 albums!), more Bowie, more Lennon, a big release from Serge Gainsbourg, Zeppelin comes back up (sorry I didn't have Led Zeppelin III so nothing on them today), Elton John, Jean Knight, Janis Joplin, Paul McCartney at last, an actual Curtis Mayfield album, Shaft, more Kristofferson & Cohen, Sticky Fingers, yet another Beach Boys album, Carole King, CAN (OMG), What's Going On, Who's Next

So...yeah. mostly funk/soul and folk but some significant rock & roll coming up, including Tago Mago by Can. Righteous.